Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Are you happy with American Idol's Top 12?
if not, who do you think should or shouldn't be there?
Personally, I would trade David H and Kristy Lee (especially after their disasters this week) to have Danny and Asia'h back.
I think Josiah should be there too, but he's probably better without Idol.
12 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
I don't know who I'd trade out, but I would definitely bring Danny & Asia'h back - more Danny though. I cried when he got voted off :( but hopefully it won't be the last we see of him.
- 1 decade ago
Yep for the most part. I think asia'h should be in the top 12 instead of Carly. And otherwise I think we have a pretty good top 12. Better than last year for sure. I do agree that David H. was a disaster tonight, I'm thinking he will probably leave this week. I also think Archuleta was a Disaster but he has done really well in the past so he will make it through no problem.
My favorite is Brooke White. Her performance earlier tonight was I think the best this season. I just helped create a new Brooke fansite and you are welcome to come and look around and join if you want.
Source(s): I review the contestants after every performance at Idol Unofficial. Check It Out! http://idol-unofficial.com/portal.htm - 1 decade ago
well, last week when it came down to asia'h and kristy for the girls, i think asia'h should have stayed...and based on the performance tonight, i think asia'h could have done a lot better on a song than what kristy did...plus, i think danny should have stayed, though i truly don't know who he would be traded with...i would have chosen him over chikezie[or however you spell it], but if i could personally pick someone out to place danny in, it would have to be david h. i think the top 12 is just ok, but i think the "rockers" in the competition get praised too often, but when someone comes out and sings a ballad, the judges are never satisfied...
:]
that's just my opinion...
- 1 decade ago
I agree with you. Although David Archuleta is my absolute favortie of all time, Danny and Asia'h were really good. I like Amanda Overmyer, but I think that sometimes she yells so much its hard to understand her. I think this year the idol is going to be one of the boys. (cough, David Archuleta) I totally agree with you about trading.
- ?Lv 45 years ago
without danny a nd asiah the suitable 12 isn't something.heavily, human beings like amanda and kristy lee prepare dinner and chikezie do no longer even need to be there..i presumed this became going to be an remarkable season yet now im fairly upset :(
- 1 decade ago
josiah was alrightt.. but i dont think i would have him in the top 12..i would want joey catalano in the top 12 (the one who couldnt sing in round 2 b/c of the flu and strep throat)and i would want asia'h back... but besides that....
DAVID ARCHULETA IS GOING TO WINNN <3 =] !!!!
Source(s): joey catalano is my cousin =] - 1 decade ago
Hmmm, I think Kristy Lee Cook is going home tomorrow. She did awful tonight and the judges hated her performance.
I liked Asia'h...I wish she wouldn't have left :(
Source(s): I am obsessed! - Anonymous1 decade ago
That show is still going on? What is this, American Idol 32?
- 1 decade ago
yes, josiah, was a Huge let down, but the Australian is good, and JakeezyEzyy is good too. :D
- Anonymous1 decade ago
yea i guess, the only one i like is Ramiele Malubay and David Archuleta is ok
